The Bowe Bergdahl Thing

Bergdahl - 1 This morning I am a little angry.  I apologize up front if any of our readers are upset about what I am going to say here, but I participate in this forum and I am going to use it. I have to admit I am a little torn over what has transpired in regard to Bowe Bergdahl.  I am torn because I am former military, I am a patriot, and I am a father.  Additionally, I feel like we have not heard all of this story.

This is not about me, so I really don’t want to address my role in the Navy.  But let me be clear, I would not have expected this to happen to me.  If I had been captured, I would have followed military protocol, and the rules of the Geneva Convention, and would have dealt with being a POW.  So having said that, it would never have happened because I would not have wandered away from my base.  A FORWARD OPERATING Base, without my body armor or weapon.  I feel like the vast majority, I would guess 95% or better, of currently deployed or enlisted military men and women would say, “You would have found me dead of multiple gunshot wounds, laying in a pile of my spent brass”.

I cannot and will not speculate on why Bowe Bergdahl would leave his base, or why he would leave his base without his weapon or body armor, but IF that is what he did, then he is not a hero or a POW, he is a deserter.  And if he is a deserter, the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Punitive Article 86 states the following:

“Any member of the armed forces who, without authority, fails to go to his appointed place of duty at the time prescribed, goes from that place; or absents himself or remain absent from his unit, organization or place of duty, at which he is required to be at the time prescribed; shall be punished as a court-martial may direct.”

So it seems to me, the minute Bergdahl’s unit discovered his weapon and body armor, and he was gone with no sign of a struggle, he was AWOL.  Maybe these are strong words.  But what the President potentially has done, is exchange five (5) criminals for one (1) criminal.

Now to on to Bowe Bergdahl’s parents.  As a father I cannot imagine and honestly don’t want to imagine, what it feels like to have a child missing or presumed dead.  I cannot guarantee I would not have acted similarly to how they have acted.  Secondly, based on how my wife responded to a bloody nose this weekend, I can guarantee she would be hysterical. So, Mr. and Mrs. Bergdahl, how do you look the rest of the deployed parents in the eye? Because whether you believe it or not, directly by your actions, and those of your President, you have put, not only other service men and women in greater danger, but Americans as whole in greater danger.

So here are the Bergdahl Five:

  • Mohammad Fazi: Former Taliban minister of defense, and Army chief, according to Human Rights Watch, guilty of a number of war crimes, including mass killings.
  • Mullah Norullah Noori: A senior commander of the Taliban and Governor of the Balkh and Laghamn provinces.
  • Mohammed Nabi: A senior Taliban official, who has ties to the Haqqani terrorist network and was the Chief of Security in Qalat, Afghanistan.
  • Khairullah Khairkhwa: A senior Taliban official with strong ties to Mullah Omar and Osama Bin Laden, including serving as Governor of the Herat province.
  • Abdul Haq Wasiq: The Taliban’s Deputy Chief of Intelligence and has strong ties to Mullah Omar.

I suggest we remember these names, because I don’t think this will be the last time we hear them.  I just hope for our sake, the next time we hear their names it is because there is another burial at sea.

I certainly don’t see much leadership exhibited in what has come out so far.


Photo credit: U.S. Army Alaska / Foter / Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic (CC BY 2.0)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

I am a Christian, a Husband and a Father, in that order. Leadership is important to me, because I see too many outside influences acting on the lives of my children, and I need support to make sure I am the most dominant influence. I appreciate your feedback and enjoy reading your input. Thanks in advance for being part of this endeavor.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.